Published by Dolly

Category: Movies & TV

Props: 1

Report

TADC in Retrospect

This is a TADC critique/ramble.

The Amazing Digital Circus was a show I really enjoyed when it first came out. It was silly, fun, and could be funny. I kept tabs on episode release dates and avoided spoilers as much as possible. I was committed to the show!

Unfortunately, the finale disappointed me. That episode was the one time I saw spoilers, so that sucked, but I lied to myself enough to go into it with some ambiguity. Spoilers aside, I found it so underwhelming.

It caused me to take a step back and look at the show as a whole. When the episodes were coming out, I was hyped. Only when the excitement ended did I realise, hey, this show is not as good as I thought it was. Not nearly as good at all. The pacing felt rushed, the characters were underutilized, and so many questions were left unanswered.

The lore about C&A was dumped in the last few episodes. It was too heavy, but still gave little information that did not directly relate to the characters' immediate goals. We do not know what C&A was actually doing and why. How were they funded? Why did random citizens give up their brain scans, and how come they never interacted with the computers or hosting the circus? The circus was created in the 1990s, but clearly ran into the last decade. Why?

Jax is also annoying. I like the idea of a closeted trans person being haunted by the circus. FYI, although I strongly oppose dropping major lore explanations on social media instead of within the show, Gooseworx confirmed Jax is a trans woman. I will refer to Jax with she/her.

Thing is, she just sucks. When she abstracted, I felt no sympathy for her outside of, "Damn. Guess that sucks for everyone." She was not redeemed by dying. Pomni's monologue about her abstraction bored me. This is supposed to be Pomni's show, not Jax's, so why is all the attention on the damn rabbit?!

Gangle was my favourite character. I also really liked Ragatha. Like all of the cast, though, they were flat.

Gangle's depression is not delved into enough. Why did she give up on art? How does she truly feel about Jax when she is not crying? How does she feel about her masks openly displaying and controlling her emotions? Most importantly for me, how did she actually fucking feel about Jax?! I find it so unrealistic that one tiny talk with Zooble bandaged things enough for her to exit her room.

Ragatha was bullied to hell and back. She is too nice, which is excellent in a character, but not enough was done with this. I liked the scene with her and Kinger in the aquarium. It was nice to see her mask break. Still, I wanted to see more of her backstory.

Zooble's body dysmorphia could have been so good if Goose actually expanded on it. What do you mean they just get over it?! That is so unsatisfying! I remember, even when I was actively watching the show, thinking that was a stupid writing move. They were setting up—albeit too late in the show to set up—an arc about body insecurity.

We could have gotten more information on Zooble's gender and how this interacts with their self-image. Imagine if Zooble clocked Jax being a closeted trans person. Imagine them actually talking. If Jax was to be redeemed, imagine her striking up a rocky amicability with Zooble over being gender diverse. Alternatively, she could become jealous of them, or fear having to face herself.

Kinger should have dealt with the pain of his memory loss more. He could have had a scene in the dark, begging not to be dragged to the light. He could have scribbled notes in his pillow fort, then having no clue who created the notes once he exits. He should forget his wife's real face, then her voice, then certain mannerisms. Drag that man to hell and back! He really felt like he just existed to dump lore and say the right things to comfort the others.

Pomni. Oh, dear Pomni. The protagonist of the show who got less of a story than Jax. The protagonist who adjustsd far too well to the circus. The protagonist whose previous life involved: urban exploration; being an accountant; and something else, probably, maybe. She was done so dirty.

The show could have given her a great previous life. I am not saying her not being traumatises prior to the circus is a bad thing. Actually, being the only person not traumatised could have been really interesting. She could have felt guilty for suffering while others had a whole other life on top of it. She could have missed her family deeply. She could have scorned herself for staying at a soul-sucking job. The circus could have been extremely traumatic for her, and we could have seen a character try to navigate trauma for the first time.

Finally, this show is not a psychological horror. The first episode was the build-up to psychological horror, but it was not scary for me. The following episodes were more like straight comedies with some adult humour. Marketing TADC as a horror show was straight-up a lie.

Big disclaimer that you can enjoy the show. I still like the show—kind of—even if I find it very flawed. No show is perfect, and to expect people to only like "good" shows is bad. Also, I am just one person. My opinions are not universal or final.

Comments

Log in to add a comment.

Aw man if they did that to Kinger I probably would've died he's my favourite of the cast 😭

But yes I completely agree!! All of the characters had so much potential to be greater. Gangle's episode genuinely intrigued me and I wish they could have expanded on it more in the other episodes. From how I interpreted it Gangle and Jax's relationship was essentially bullying and abuse, so why the heck didn't they do more for her reaction to her abstraction?!

Then there's Kinger. I'm VERY grateful that they didn't give him an abolutely horrendous backstory but seriously he needed to have a vulnerable scene at some point in the show? I completely agree with you that he was just used as a kind of mentor figure. Like COME ONNNN PEOPLE HE'S GONE THROUGH STUFF JUST LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE.

I also especially love your idea for a Zooble and Jax interaction. That would have made for great drama why ddn't they use that?? Oh my goodness.

My last little comment is just the ending overall. It's probably the happiest ending the show could have gotten, but somehow if it was meant to be a horror then having it that the characters final situations were more grim would've been more intriguing. There's a lot I wish could have been done, but yeah. I suppose that's just TADC.

In short I totally agree with you!! <(_ _)>
No, yeah, Kinger being tormented would have hurt a lot, but I think it would have been more rewarding. I was really interested in his character.

Goose stated on her Tumblr that Gangle was supposed to have some kind of attachment to Jax. She also said Jax does not recognise herself as an abuser. Why was this not expanded upon in the show?

The lack of anything regarding Scratch or the other circus members pissed me off. We know Scratch had a brain tumour. That's it. Who was he? Why did he create the circus? What about the other AI C&A made? How did Caine break free from his enclosure, absorb another AI, and take complete control of the circus? You're telling me nobody from the real world could just delete him?

I'm glad you like my idea for Zooble and Jax!

I think that, even in a psychological horror scenario, TADC could have ended with something similar. I would place the brain scan reveal an episode or two beforehand, though. The characters should have had time to feel horrified and hopeless. Then, they can pull up their pants and decide to make the circus their new home.